Costa Rica Post

Pura Vida, Every Day
Tuesday, Apr 22, 2025

Legal Challenge Raised Against Cultural Declaration Decree in Costa Rica

Legal Challenge Raised Against Cultural Declaration Decree in Costa Rica

Attorney Giovanni Delgado contests the new regulations introduced by President Rodrigo Chaves and Minister Jorge Rodríguez for potentially violating citizen rights.
Giovanni Delgado, an attorney and member of the Marcha de la Diversidad organization in Costa Rica, has filed a constitutional appeal against President Rodrigo Chaves and Minister of Culture Jorge Rodríguez regarding a recently enacted decree that partially reforms the regulations for declaring cultural interest.

Delgado contends that the new regulations infringe upon rights related to association, freedom of expression, and religious freedom.

The decree modifies several articles of the existing regulations with the intention of clarifying and detailing the requirements that cultural projects or products must meet to be recognized as of cultural interest.

Delgado has expressed concern that these changes may violate constitutional and human rights and undermine the promotion of cultural life and the protection of artistic heritage.

The appeal is currently under review for admissibility, assigned the case number 25-007637-0007-CO. Delgado has also requested precautionary measures from the court due to the alleged rights violations and the constitutional principles at stake.

One modification highlighted by Delgado as problematic is Article 4, which outlines activities, groups, collectives, projects, or cultural products that are “not eligible for declaration as of cultural interest.” He argues that this provision implies a prejudicial exclusion of various organizations and groups from obtaining such recognition.

Specifically, Article 4 states that groups, associations, foundations, collectives, television channels, radio stations, cultural houses, cultural centers, academies, and any other organization or site are ineligible for cultural interest declarations.

Additionally, cultural activities, projects, or products of a religious nature are also excluded unless they are intended to support cultural expressions linked to declarations of intangible cultural heritage, backed by specific laws or conventions.

Delgado asserts that this article could be subject to ambiguous interpretations, given historical precedent where certain groups have previously received cultural interest recognition.

He argues that this restriction violates the right to association, enabling individuals to form groups without contravening legal norms, and poses a threat to religious and expressive freedoms.

The attorney further notes a contradiction in Article 2, which prohibits cultural declarations from resulting in fiscal, financial, or material benefits from the state while simultaneously empowering the Ministry of Public Works and Transport (MOPT) to consider cultural declarations as “of public interest” under its own regulations, potentially allowing for the use of public spaces.

Despite the administration’s rationale of refining regulatory concepts, Delgado points out that the amendments lack specific technical parameters or criteria detailing how a cultural interest declaration can be revoked.

He believes there are sufficient legal grounds to foresee that the appeal will be accepted for thorough examination, with a possibility of declaring the decree invalid as published in La Gaceta.

Furthermore, Delgado claims that Chaves and Rodríguez are transgressing various articles of the Political Constitution, including Articles 1, 25, 28, 67, 75, and 89. He asserts that they are also violating provisions of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which ensures the freedom of thought, religion, and the right to access and enjoy cultural life, as well as the Inter-American Convention on Human Rights, which establishes rights related to peaceful assembly, association based on interests, equality before the law, and the enjoyment of cultural development.

The implications of the decree extend to notable events such as the 2024 March of Pride.

In June 2024, Chaves revoked the cultural interest declaration for the March of Pride one day before the event was scheduled to take place.

In response, Giovanni Delgado filed an appeal against the president, which was ruled in his favor by the Constitutional Chamber.

The ruling determined that Chaves had flagrantly violated the fundamental rights of a vulnerable minority population, specifically the LGTBIQ+ community.

The court concluded that while a cultural interest declaration does not guarantee fiscal or material benefits, it significantly impacts societal visibility and awareness towards the event and its target population.

Following the revocation, it was noted that the organizers had complied with all procedural requirements in a manner consistent with past years, with the declaration previously endorsed by the then Minister of Culture, Nayuribe Guadamuz, and Jorge Rodríguez on behalf of President Chaves.

On the evening of June 29, the day the revocation was announced, Chaves also dismissed Guadamuz from her position as the head of Culture and Youth, asserting that she had managed the declaration without his authorization or that of his office.

That same day, the president also removed the Commissioner for Social Inclusion, Ricardo Sossa Ortiz, from his post.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Global Leaders Pay Tribute to Pope Francis Following His Death
El Salvador Proposes Prisoner Exchange with Venezuela Amid Deportation Controversy
US Government Defends Deportation of Salvadoran National Kilmar Abrego Garcia
A casino in Mexico burns at the hands of cartels
Pope Francis Makes Brief Appearance at Easter Sunday Mass
"Some complain that we put thousands in prison. In reality, we set millions free."
US Judge Blocks Trump Administration's Rapid Deportation Policy
U.S. State Department Raises El Salvador’s Safety Ranking, Making It Safer Than France and Other European Nations
U.S. and Panama Finalize Defense Agreements Amid Canal Access and Chinese Influence Concerns
Alisha Lehmann's Modeling Campaign and Public Controversy Stir Debate Ahead of UEFA Women's Euro
Argentina's "Magician" or a Public Relations Illusion? "Individuals Are Sifting Through Garbage and Resting on the Sidewalks."
Ecuador Gears Up for US Military Deployment in Response to Action Against Violent Drug Cartels
The Trump administration has rescinded legal status for more than 530,000 migrants hailing from four nations.
Trump Administration's Deportation of Alleged Gang Members Sparks Legal Dispute
Deadly Tornadoes and Dust Storms Lead to 33 Deaths in Central and Southern United States
Mark Carney Chosen as Leader of Canada's Liberal Party, Poised to Become Prime Minister
Trump Administration Plans New Travel Ban Including Afghanistan and Pakistan
US Announces $10 Million Bounty for Capture of Ex-Olympic Snowboarder Now Drug Kingpin
El Salvador Pursues Extradition of Former Colonel Tied to 1982 Killings of Dutch Journalists.
U.S. Creates Strategic Cryptocurrency Reserve, Sparking Market Surge
Research Explores Possible Connection Between COVID-19 Vaccines and Post-Vaccination Syndrome
Latin America News Synopsis: Gatherings, Legal Disputes, and Economic Developments
Mexico Offers Constitutional Amendments to Protect Sovereignty in Response to U.S. Terrorist Labels for Cartels
Tequila Sector Faces Oversupply Challenge as Agave Prices Drop Sharply
Costa Rica to Welcome Repatriated Migrants from the United States
New York Fashion Week Showcases Iconic Comebacks and Rising Stars
OpenAI Revises Its Approach in Response to Growing AI Competition
Trump Wins Again as Canada Agrees to Strengthen Border Security
Wall Street Journal Criticizes Trump's Trade War with Canada and Mexico
Trump Freezes Tariffs on Mexico After Agreement on Border Security
Apple Abandons AR Glasses Project Amid Struggles with Technology and Market Demand
U.S. Clinical Study Investigates Medication to Prolong Dogs' Lifespan
Trump: Canada Should Become the 51st U.S. State
Panama Rules Out Negotiations With US Over Control of Canal
The 'Chinese Pearl Harbor' on U.S. Tech: DeepSeek's Launch Triggers Market Collapse
Key Takeaways from the 2025 World Economic Forum in Davos
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink Suggests Bitcoin Could Reach $700,000 with Increased Institutional Investment
Five Billionaires on Track to Break One Trillion Dollar Wealth Barrier
Celebrity Responses to California Wildfires: Charity, Criticism, and Controversy
Saprissa Withdraws from Costa Rica's Women's Soccer First Division, Sparking Debate and Concern
Miguel Herrera: Farewell Video from Fox Sports as He Takes on Costa Rica National Team
Controversial Reappointment: Costa Rican President Rodrigo Chaves Names Marta Esquivel as Planning Minister
A Long Battle Ends in Tragedy for Shooting Victim in Costa Rica
Triple Homicide in Los Chiles: Couple and Five-Year-Old Girl Fatally Shot
Horacio Elizondo Resigns Irrevocably from Costa Rica's Football Federation Amidst Controversy
Costa Rican Digital Vehicle Licensing Bid Faces Another Setback
Convict Recaptured After Brief Escape from La Reforma Prison Complex
José Giacone: Confident in Saprissa's Enhanced Competitiveness This Season
Costa Rican President Rodrigo Chaves Considers Shift to Congressional Leadership
Pope Francis Praises Costa Rican Coffee as the World's Best
×